The Lifestyle Bloc and the Diversified Cohort
Isaiah Berlin’s famous essay divided thinkers into two types: hedgehogs, who know one big thing, and foxes, who know many things. If you want proof that the metaphor extends beyond the ivory tower, consider the latest NBC News Decision Desk poll of Generation Z.
On one side are the hedgehogs—Harris voters who form a Lifestyle Bloc united around a single vision of success: career fulfillment and money to enjoy life. On the other are the foxes—Trump voters who make up a Diversified Cohort, spreading their values across children, marriage, financial independence, homeownership, and faith. One side is cohesive, the other varied. One side is narrow, the other broad.
The NBC News Decision Desk asked 2,970 adults aged 18 to 29 to rank their top three priorities among 12 choices for defining personal success. The choices were: having a fulfilling job or career, having money to do things you want, achieving financial independence, having emotional stability, using talents and resources to help others, owning your own home, making family or community proud, having no debt, being married, being grounded spiritually, having children, and being able to retire early.
NBC framed this as a gender gap story, and it’s true that men and women diverge sharply in their views of Trump—74 percent of young women disapprove of his job performance compared to just 53 percent of young men. But the deeper divide runs along political lines.
The Lifestyle Bloc: Gen Z’s Harris Hedgehogs
Harris voters cluster tightly around their choices. More than half include having a fulfilling job or career in their top three definitions of success—54 percent of Gen Z Harris men and 51 percent of Gen Z Harris women. Nearly as many rank having enough money to do what you want in their top three—46 percent of women and 42 percent of men. A third priority emerges: using talents and resources to help others, which 38 percent of men and 37 percent of women include in their rankings.
Marriage and children rank at the very bottom—just six percent of Harris women include marriage in their top three priorities, and the same percentage choose having children. Among Harris men, 11 percent include marriage and nine percent choose children in their top three. Even financial independence, once the gold standard of middle-class success, gets selected by only 29 percent of men and 32 percent of women.
This focus makes the Lifestyle Bloc classic hedgehogs. They know one big thing: work and lifestyle matter above all else. Their worldview is cohesive, disciplined, and predictable. But it’s also narrow, brittle, and vulnerable. The Harris voters march in lockstep to the tune of the career and consumerism siren song.
The one place this unity among the Harris Hedgehogs breaks down is emotional stability. Thirty-nine percent of Harris women include this in their top three, while just 29 percent of Harris men do. That 10-point gap is the widest among an otherwise unified generational bloc.
The Diversified Cohort: Gen Z’s Trump Foxes
Trump voters spread their choices differently. The top selection among Trump men—34 percent—goes to having children. Trump women put financial independence first at 40 percent. Both groups include marriage, homeownership, and spiritual grounding in their top three more often than their Harris peers. Yet no single value dominates the way “fulfilling job” does among Harris voters.
This distribution makes them the Diversified Cohort—true foxes who balance multiple priorities simultaneously: family, faith, independence, and finance. Trump men elevate children and marriage. Trump women champion financial self-reliance. Between them, they cover wide terrain without converging on any single definition of success.
Politics: The Fox Strategy vs. The Hedgehog Strategy
You might assume the hedgehogs’ unity gives them a political advantage. But their tight consensus around career and lifestyle creates a clear bloc that’s also a narrow one. The Lifestyle Bloc is easy to describe, but it means there is very little room for dissent or heterodoxy. If you don’t fit it, you are out of place.
Trump’s foxes present a different challenge precisely because they’re harder to pin down. Some respond to appeals about family and children, others to messages about financial independence, still others to themes of faith and community. A coalition that values many things can be mobilized in many ways. While Harris maintained her lead among Gen Z overall, Trump’s diversified approach helped him close gaps that might have been wider with a more conventional campaign focused on single issues.
Economics: Two Futures Taking Shape
The economic futures these worldviews suggest couldn’t be more different. The Lifestyle Bloc, with children and marriage ranking dead last, points toward lower fertility, delayed family formation, and an economy built around individual experiences and optimization.
The Diversified Cohort suggests something else entirely—higher fertility rates, stronger family networks, and economic demand that spans both individual achievement and community building.
One group knows exactly what it wants but struggles to see beyond that vision. The other wants many things at once, which creates both complexity and flexibility.
The hedgehogs are building a society optimized for individual achievement and curated experiences. The foxes are betting on diversified lives anchored by family, faith, and financial independence.
Read the full article here